Six Stars Out Of Five

-


Janine and I had an interesting discussion about internet ratings and their usefulness. I figured the thoughts I had amassed would work out in a nice post along with suggestions that I have for making ratings work for our benefit. Hopefully this will not be a mental dump, but something meaningful.

We've all seen several types of ratings. We have the classic 0-5 stars, thumbs up/thumbs down, number ratings from 0-10, number ratings from 0-3, and the list goes on and on. Janine stated that the ratings found on Google Local (0-3) was ineffective in her finding valuable ratings. I completely agree with her assessment, but I don't think the problem lies with the rating system, but with the people who are using the rating system.

People typically take to the internet to rate an item or service for two reasons: They either had great service or they had horrible service, and they feel obligated to warn or encourage others to use or not use that service. I've often found the lowest and highest ratings to be actually ineffective. I've only found better value in the people who give middle of the road ratings than either extreme.

The only exception would be for an item, app, or service that had exclusively great or poor ratings. Great ratings encourages me that everyone has had a great experience and naturally all poor ratings warns me that something is inherently wrong and to seek alternates. I feel comfortable that within unanimous consent the ratings actually help me make the best decisions.

The other factor falls as a side effect of branding. With branding, people tend to create fan bases. A great example would be the competition between iPhone and Android. Fanboys in both camps tend to cloud an impartial rating between the devices primarily due to extreme loyalty to one brand and disdain for the other brand. I wanted to site a source, but simply go to any Android or iPhone article and the comments are flooded with these raging fan debates.

So once again, I'm stuck in the middle. On sites like Yelp or Google/Zagat, I look for the people who give a varied response to a product or service. With some digging down and by seeing comments, I can better discern if someone is giving a fair rating, or just being a jerk. As long as a rating system has a wide chart for ratings, categories, and mandating commenting, we can better use this internet to judge what is worth checking out and what is worth avoiding.

The biggest fix for web ratings is going to be a return of responsible ratings by responsible people. It's up to us to provide better feedback using reason and fairness. These sites are great for those that want to rant and rave whenever someone has offered superior or poor service, but we all need better tools in determining if those circumstances were unique or the norm. So I give the internet one thumb up and hope over time I can give it two thumbs up.

Popular posts from this blog

For My Friend

-
Image
I moved to Richmond in September, full of aprehension. Many of you by keeping up with my story know full well the ups and downs that I have faced. I was very fortunate to land a great job in October. After a lot of rejection, and fear for losing everything I started my new job with that same fear I had when I moved to this city. I was crammed in an office with Kelly Stern. He is such a kind, patient, gentle soul. He showed me around and I got comfortable working there really fast. I smile when I remember one of my coworkers talking about us giggling in there all day. I had fun those days. It did not take me long to find out that Kelly was gay. He mentioned living with Jeff, and I put two and two together fast. Kelly listened to my troubles, and gave me sound, firm advice. He has been so helpful to me also by taking me home from work almost every day and taking me by the grocery store to get supplies. I would not still be here if it was not for his help. I cannot think of a way to
Read more

The Drowning Death Spiral of Modern Political Debates

-
Image
There's nothing like a tragic loss of life for people to tout their political beliefs. And it's so much easier in this social media age. As I've noted many times before though, there's a lot less discourse now and a lot more shouting and yelling. The weekend tragedy in Orlando is a sad and depressing example of this showboating. In the midst of evil and intolerance, sides have geared up to discuss the merits of gun control again. Yet I don't really hear a coherent debate. What I hear are two sides screaming about two narratives that don't mesh together at all. Picture two children arguing. One wants a video game and the other one wants to eat. The focus is in two different arenas, food and fun. On one side of the gun debate are people who are strong advocates of constitutional jurisprudence. Passing increased measures to limit a law abiding citizen access to weapons, they believe, will not solve the problem of evil that exists when a bad person obtains o
Read more

My Wiiview

-
Image
You all may be familiar with my Wii saga. Janine told me on my birthday in March that we were going to purchase the console which made me very happy. I figured both of us would be able to enjoy the Wii so it was a better value. Being at least two hundred dollars cheaper than the other new consoles help make that an easy decision too. Little did we know that we were in the midst of trying to find one the most sought after pieces of hardware since Tickle Me Elmo. I remember going to at least 5 stores in March only to find laughter when asked if they had any of these Wiis in stock. The manager of one store even told me that if I get in early enough, there may be two consoles, but I better bring a bat because the soccer moms trying to find them as well may have rabies. So Janine and I pretty much gave up on finding the new Nintendo console until last week when I was shopping for her iPod Nano. Sitting there in the back of the store were three Wiis. So now I have my toy hooked up and after
Read more